The Four Turning, The Five Elements and Carl Jung’s Archetypes

“The Fourth Turning” by William Strauss and Neil Howe articulates a generational theory of history. The authors posit that societies undergo recurring cycles, referred to as “turnings,” approximately every 80-100 years. These cycles consist of four distinct generational archetypes of the Prophet, the Nomad, the Hero, and the Artist. Each archetype plays a significant role in shaping and responding to historical events in predictable patterns.

The four turnings are:

The High – A period of societal rebuilding after a crisis, characterized by strong institutions, collective unity, and optimism (e.g., post-WWII boom in the U.S.).

The Awakening – A cultural period where individuals challenge established norms, emphasizing personal and spiritual values over conformity (e.g., the 1960s counterculture movement).

The Unraveling – Institutions weaken, individualism increases, and trust in government and societal structures declines (e.g., 1980s-2000s in the U.S.).

The Crisis (Fourth Turning) – Significant upheaval, such as war, economic downturns, or revolution, that forces society to reconstruct itself (e.g., the Great Depression and WWII).

According to their theory, the U.S. is currently in a Fourth Turning (beginning around 2008), indicating we’re in a period of crisis and transformation that will likely peak in the 2020s before leading into a new High. William Strauss and Neil Howe’s generational theory primarily focuses on Western historical cycles. They did not explicitly incorporate Eastern philosophies like Taoism or the Wu Xing (Five Elements) into their framework. Their analysis centers on patterns observed in Anglo-American history, detailing a recurring cycle of four generational archetypes where the Prophet, Nomad, Hero, and Artist, each influence societal moods and events over approximately 80-100 years.,

The Wu Xing in Taoist philosophy describes five interrelated elements of Wood, Fire, Earth, Metal, and Water, each associated with specific seasons, times of day, and life phases. This system emphasizes balance and the dynamic interactions between elements, reflecting the cyclical nature of the universe.

While both frameworks recognize cyclical patterns, their foundations differ: the Wu Xing is rooted in natural elements and their interactions, whereas the Strauss-Howe theory is based on generational dynamics and historical events. There isn’t direct evidence that Strauss and Howe studied or integrated Eastern philosophies into their work.

Carl Jung, a Swiss psychiatrist and psychoanalyst, introduced the idea of psychological archetypes and was significantly influenced by his study of Eastern philosophies. Jung’s incorporation of concepts from Taoism, Buddhism, and other Eastern traditions into his work on the collective unconscious and archetypes predated the Strauss-Howe generational theory by decades. While Strauss and Howe developed their own unique framework focused on historical and generational patterns, the notion of archetypes they used resonates with the broader tradition of exploring recurring patterns in human behavior and culture.

However, the concept of cyclical patterns is present in many cultural philosophies, suggesting a universal human inclination to find order and predictability in history and nature. While the specifics of the cycles differ between the Wu Xing and the Strauss-Howe generational theory, both offer perspectives on understanding the rhythms and transformations inherent in societies.

“Hard times create strong men. Strong men create good times. Good times create weak men. And, weak men create hard times.”

― G. Michael Hopf, Those Who Remain

Universal Cycles of Transformation

Each framework describes a repeating sequence of phases, with distinct yet interrelated roles:

Strauss & Howe’s Fourth Turning follows a four-phase generational cycle (~80-100 years), where societal moods shift from stability (High) to questioning (Awakening), fragmentation (Unraveling), and renewal through crisis (Crisis).

Wu Xing (Five Elements) describes a five-phase natural cycle (Wood, Fire, Earth, Metal, Water), applied to time, seasons, and human life. Taoism sees a person’s lifespan in ~25-year segments:

0-8 (Spring) – sprouting of one’s identity

8-33 (Summer) – flowering of one’s vitality

33-58 (Late Summer) – fruition of what has been achieved

58-83 (Autumn) – cutting away what is not needed

83-108 (Winter) – transformation and rebirth

All phases closely mirror The Fourth Turning’s phases.

Jungian Archetypes reflect psychological transformations across an individual’s life and history. His concepts of Hero, Wise Old Man, Shadow, and Rebirth mirror the rise, crisis, and renewal patterns seen in the other two theories. Jung, influenced by Taoism and the I Ching, recognized life as a process of individuation—balancing opposing forces (Yin-Yang, conscious-unconscious), much like the generational and elemental cycles.

Key Takeaways:

Generational, Natural, and Psychological Patterns Are Interwoven
Each theory observes cyclical phases that repeat over time, whether in history (Fourth Turning), nature (Wu Xing), or the psyche (Jungian archetypes).

Crisis and renewal are fundamental to change, whether societal, elemental, or personal.

Strauss & Howe’s Generational Theory May Unconsciously Reflect Jungian Archetypes
The Fourth Turning’s generational archetypes (Prophet, Nomad, Hero, Artist) resemble Jung’s archetypal roles.

Jung, who studied Taoism and Eastern philosophy, recognized cycles of transformation, much like Wu Xing’s elemental shifts.

Taoism’s Wu Xing and Jung’s Individuation Both Emphasize Balance
Wu Xing describes the dynamic interplay of elements, where excess in one leads to transformation into another.

Jung’s individuation process requires integrating all aspects of the psyche, much like how Taoist balance ensures harmony.

Crisis is a Necessary Stage for Renewal
Fourth Turning: Each crisis (e.g., WWII) paves the way for societal rebirth.

Wu Xing: Death and decay (Metal & Water) are necessary before new life (Wood).

Jung: Transformation only occurs when the individual faces their Shadow and integrates unconscious aspects.
Though emerging from different traditions, these three theories reveal a shared truth: transformation occurs through cyclical forces, shaping societies, nature, and individuals alike. Whether through generational change, elemental shifts, or psychological evolution, the rhythm of crisis and renewal is an eternal pattern in human experience.

References:
Generations X и Y: Crux, Characteristics, Application of a Theory in Recruiting. (2023). https://itluckyhunter.com/blog/generations-theory

I teach and offer lectures about holistic health, physical fitness, stress management, human behavior, meditation, phytotherapy (herbs), music for healing, self-massage (acupressure), Daoyin (yoga), qigong, tai chi, and baguazhang.

Please contact me if you, your business, organization, or group, might be interested in hosting me to speak on a wide spectrum of topics relative to better health, fitness, and well-being.

I look forward to further sharing more of my message by partnering with hospitals, wellness centers, VA centers, schools on all levels, businesses, and individuals who see the value in building a stronger nation through building a healthier population.

I also have hundreds of FREE education video classes, lectures, and seminars available on my YouTube channel at:

https://www.youtube.com/c/MindandBodyExercises

Many of my publications can be found on Amazon at:

http://www.Amazon.com/author/jimmoltzan

My holistic health blog is available at:

https://mindandbodyexercises.wordpress.com/

http://www.MindAndBodyExercises.com

Mind and Body Exercises on Google: https://posts.gle/aD47Qo

Jim Moltzan

407-234-0119

The Detriments of Social Media: A Closer Look at Polarizing Behavior

Social media has become an integral part of modern life, offering a platform for self-expression, networking, and information sharing. However, when individuals, especially those with professional careers, use social media to constantly post their political and social views, it can lead to unintended consequences. This behavior, particularly when it involves posting dozens of times a day with little engagement, can be polarizing and may negatively impact both personal and professional relationships. Beyond the social and professional risks, this kind of behavior can also have significant psychological and physiological effects, including stress, cortisol imbalances, and even obsessive-compulsive tendencies.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-social-media-is-so-good-at-polarizing-us-11603105204

The Professional Risks

One of the most immediate detriments of excessive posting of polarizing views is the potential harm to one’s professional reputation. For individuals with established careers, social media often extends their professional identity. When their online presence is dominated by divisive political or social commentary, it can overshadow their expertise and accomplishments. Colleagues, clients, or professional networks with differing views may feel alienated, leading to strained relationships or missed opportunities. In extreme cases, this behavior can even result in job loss or damage to one’s career trajectory, as employers increasingly scrutinize employees’ online activity.

Engagement and Feedback

Another notable issue is the lack of engagement these posts often receive. When individuals post frequently and assertively, framing their views as absolute truths, it can discourage others from responding. People may find the content unrelatable, exhausting, or confrontational, leading to a lack of meaningful dialogue. Over time, this can create an echo chamber where the individual only hears their own voice, further entrenching their beliefs and isolating them from diverse perspectives. This lack of engagement can also be a sign that their approach is counterproductive, as it fails to foster the kind of constructive conversations that could lead to mutual understanding.

https://www.emarketer.com/content/social-media-boost-mental-health-millennials

A Shift in How We Engage with Perspectives

In the past, before the advent of social media, people often engaged in face-to-face conversations where curiosity about others’ perspectives was more common. There was a natural inclination to ask questions, listen, and seek to understand differing viewpoints. Social media, however, has fundamentally altered this dynamic. Today, we are freely able and often inundated with the thoughts and opinions of others, sometimes to the point of oversaturation. While this transparency can foster connection, it can also lead to fatigue, especially when those opinions are expressed aggressively or excessively. The mystery and curiosity that once fueled meaningful dialogue are often replaced by a sense of overexposure, where the sheer volume of content can make it difficult to engage thoughtfully.

Psychological and Emotional Impact

The psychological and emotional toll of this behavior cannot be overlooked. Constantly posting polarizing content may stem from a deep-seated need for validation or a desire to influence others. However, when these posts go unnoticed or unacknowledged, it can lead to feelings of frustration, inadequacy, or even anger. Over time, this cycle can contribute to heightened stress levels and emotional exhaustion. Moreover, the act of repeatedly sharing strong opinions can become compulsive, resembling obsessive-compulsive tendencies. The individual may feel an uncontrollable urge to post, even when it no longer serves a constructive purpose. If someone has the time, effort, and energy to blame others for all of the world’s ills, they also have the time to reflect and focus on becoming a better version of themselves. Rather than dwelling on external problems, shifting some of that energy toward self-improvement could yield far more positive and constructive outcomes.

Respecting Passion Without Sharing It

It’s worth noting that while someone’s efforts to advocate for a cause may appear noble or well-intentioned, not everyone will share their passion or agree with their methods. Social media often amplifies the visibility of these efforts, making it seem as though everyone should be equally invested. However, it’s important to recognize that people have different priorities, values, and capacities for engagement. What one person sees as a critical issue worthy of relentless advocacy, another may view as less pressing or outside their sphere of interest. This disconnect doesn’t diminish the value of the cause itself, but it highlights the importance of respecting boundaries and understanding that not everyone will share the same level of enthusiasm or commitment.

Physiological Effects: Stress, Cortisol, and Chemical Imbalances

The psychological stress associated with excessive social media use can also manifest physiologically. Chronic stress triggers the release of cortisol, a hormone that, in excess, can disrupt the body’s natural balance. Elevated cortisol levels have been linked to a range of health issues, including anxiety, depression, sleep disturbances, and weakened immune function. For individuals who are constantly engaged in online debates or who feel compelled to post frequently, this stress response can become a persistent state, leading to long-term health consequences.

Additionally, the dopamine-driven nature of social media can exacerbate these issues. The anticipation of likes, shares, or comments triggers dopamine release, reinforcing a habit loop. Over time, this can contribute to compulsive posting, as individuals seek continued validation through online interactions. This chemical imbalance can make it difficult for individuals to step away from social media, even when they recognize its negative impact on their lives.

Constructive Approaches for Change

For individuals who find themselves caught in this cycle, there are steps they can take to create a healthier and more balanced online presence. First, they might consider diversifying their content to include professional achievements, personal interests, or neutral topics that encourage broader engagement. Framing opinions in a way that invites dialogue—such as asking, “What are your thoughts on this?”—can also foster more respectful and productive conversations. Additionally, limiting the frequency of posts and focusing on quality over quantity can help reduce the compulsive urge to share and create a more thoughtful online presence.

For Observers: Setting Boundaries and Offering Support

For those who are on the receiving end of this behavior, it’s important to set boundaries. If the constant stream of polarizing posts becomes overwhelming, muting or unfollowing the individual on social media can help maintain mental well-being while preserving professional relationships. It’s also helpful to remember that their behavior is likely a reflection of their own experiences and beliefs, not a personal attack. In some cases, offering constructive feedback—if the relationship allows—can encourage them to reflect on their approach and its impact on others.

Conclusion

While social media offers a powerful platform for self-expression, its misuse can have far-reaching consequences. For individuals who post their political and social views excessively, the risks include professional alienation, strained relationships, and psychological and physiological harm. By adopting a more balanced and thoughtful approach to social media, individuals can mitigate these detriments and create a more positive and productive online presence. For observers, setting boundaries and offering support can help navigate these challenging dynamics. Ultimately, social media is a tool, and its impact depends on how it is used. By using social media intentionally—fostering meaningful discussions rather than divisive debates—we can create a digital space that informs rather than isolates.

References:

Mims, C., & Holcroft, J. (2020, October 19). Why social media is so good at polarizing us. WSJ. https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-social-media-is-so-good-at-polarizing-us-11603105204

Professional Risks of Social Media Use

Brown, V. R., & Vaughn, E. D. (2011). The writing on the (Facebook) wall: The use of social networking sites in hiring decisions. Journal of Business and Psychology, 26(2), 219-225.

This study explores how employers evaluate candidates’ social media presence and the potential impact of polarizing content.

Echo Chambers and Engagement Issues

Pariser, E. (2011). The Filter Bubble: What the Internet Is Hiding from You. Penguin Press.

Discusses how social media algorithms reinforce pre-existing beliefs and limit exposure to diverse perspectives.

Psychological and Emotional Effects of Social Media Overuse

Twenge, J. M., Joiner, T. E., Rogers, M. L., & Martin, G. N. (2017). Increases in depressive Symptoms, Suicide-Related Outcomes, and suicide rates among U.S. adolescents after 2010 and links to increased new media screen time. Clinical Psychological Science, 6(1), 3–17. https://doi.org/10.1177/2167702617723376

Examines how excessive screen time and social media use contribute to stress, anxiety, and depression.

Physiological Impact: Stress, Cortisol, and Dopamine

Sapolsky, R. M. (2004). Why Zebras Don’t Get Ulcers. Holt Paperbacks.

Explains how chronic stress and elevated cortisol levels affect mental and physical health.

Montag, C., & Reuter, M. (2017). Internet Addiction: Neuroscientific Approaches and Therapeutical Implications Including Smartphone Addiction. Springer.

Discusses dopamine-driven social media addiction and its effect on brain function.

Please contact me if you, your business, organization, or group, might be interested in hosting me to speak on a wide spectrum of topics relative to better health, fitness, and well-being.

I also have hundreds of FREE education video classes, lectures, and seminars available on my YouTube channel at:

https://www.youtube.com/c/MindandBodyExercises

Many of my publications can be found on Amazon at:

http://www.Amazon.com/author/jimmoltzan

My holistic health blog is available at:

https://mindandbodyexercises.wordpress.com/

http://www.MindAndBodyExercises.com

Mind and Body Exercises on Google: https://posts.gle/aD47Qo

Jim Moltzan

407-234-0119

Wind and Water, Makes Fire

The human mind and body are integral parts of nature, constantly interacting with its energies. There is a direct correlation between the systems of nature and those of the body, with three key elements of wind, fire, and water, serving as points of connection.

Wind corresponds to the respiratory system, as the air we breathe sustains life.
Fire represents body temperature, which plays a vital role in all physiological functions.
Water relates to the circulatory system, essential for vitality and well-being.

Practices such as Tai Chi, Qigong, and Bagua Zhang profoundly influence the body, impacting the organs, joints, and muscles at a deep level. In Taoist alchemy, the philosophical phrase “wind and water make fire” metaphorically represents the dynamic interactions of the Five Elements (Wu Xing) and the internal processes of self-cultivation.

Here’s a breakdown of how this concept fits into Taoist thought:

Five Elements Correspondence:
- Wind (Feng, 风) is often associated with Wood (Mu, 木), which represents growth, movement, and expansion.
- Water (Shui, 水) corresponds to the Kidneys and the essence (Jing), which serves as the foundation for transformation.
- Fire (Huo, 火) corresponds to Yang energy, warmth, and spirit (Shen).
- The idea is that the interaction of movement (Wind/Wood) and nourishment (Water) can generate Fire (Yang energy, transformation).
Neidan (Internal Alchemy) Interpretation:
- Wind (Wood) and Water represent Qi and Jing, respectively.
- Their controlled interaction through breathwork, meditation, and energy circulation can generate the internal “alchemy fire” needed to refine essence into Qi and Qi into Shen.
- This fire is not literal but the internal warmth and energetic transformation that happens in deep meditation or Qigong.
Martial & Qigong Perspective:
- In advanced Qigong and martial arts, regulated breath (Wind) and internal fluid movement (Water) manifest into internal heat (Fire), leading to refined power and vitality.
- This aligns with practices of Tai Chi, Qigong and BaguaZhang, where breath, body movement, and mind-intent cultivate the internal fire for vitality and martial efficiency.

Please contact me if you, your business, organization, or group, might be interested in hosting me to speak on a wide spectrum of topics relative to better health, fitness, and well-being.

I also have hundreds of FREE education video classes, lectures, and seminars available on my YouTube channel at:

https://www.youtube.com/c/MindandBodyExercises

Many of my publications can be found on Amazon at:

http://www.Amazon.com/author/jimmoltzan

My holistic health blog is available at:

https://mindandbodyexercises.wordpress.com/

http://www.MindAndBodyExercises.com

Mind and Body Exercises on Google: https://posts.gle/aD47Qo

Jim Moltzan

407-234-0119

Pulling Back the Curtain

My new book Pulling Back the Curtain is now available through Amazon (https://a.co/d/09malCv). I offer a color reference guide for Sacred Geometry, Carl Jung’s theories, and their relevance to human behavior and symbolism. If you practice yoga, tai chi, qigong, BaguaZhang, other mind-body methods or are just looking to expand your understanding of our reality, my new book will help you organize all seemingly complex concepts.

Throughout human history, profound truths about the universe and our place within it have been explored and expressed through archetypes, geometry, psychology and philosophy. From the earliest cave drawings to the intricate mandalas of Eastern traditions, humanity has sought to map the intangible forces that shape our existence. These universal patterns reveal not only the structures of the cosmos but also the dynamics of our own inner worlds. It is this interplay between the external and internal, the visible and invisible, that this book illuminates. My intent for this book is to provide a graphical study guide that summarizes complex concepts for those already familiar with these topics, while offering an introduction for those just beginning to pursue this type of information.

The Taoist concept of yin and yang further underscores the dynamic dualities that shape our world: light and shadow, masculine and feminine, chaos and order. This dance of opposites, echoed in Jung’s theories, reminds us that life’s challenges and joys are part of a larger, harmonious whole. At the heart of these inquiries lies the work of Carl Jung, whose pioneering insights into the collective unconscious provide a framework for understanding the interconnectedness of all things. Jung’s exploration of archetypes and opposites, including the balance of yin and yang, offers profound guidance for navigating the complexities of modern life. His fascination with symbols, geometry, and universal patterns serves as a bridge between ancient wisdom and contemporary thought.

Similarly, the Platonic solids – those perfect, symmetrical forms revered by both philosophers and mystics, stand as metaphors for the foundational elements of existence. These shapes, deeply intertwined with sacred geometry, reflect the harmony and order inherent in nature. Their significance transcends mere mathematics, inviting us to ponder the deeper truths they represent. Sacred geometry ties these threads together, offering a visual language of the divine. Found in the spirals of galaxies, the structure of DNA, and the design of ancient temples, sacred geometry is both a scientific marvel and a spiritual guide. It reminds us that beauty and meaning exist not only in grand cosmic designs but also in the smallest details of our daily lives. Furthermore, sacred geometry finds profound expression in the realm of mind-body practices such as yoga, tai chi, qigong and even martial arts. These disciplines incorporate geometric principles in their movements and postures, fostering harmony within the body and between the individual and the universe. The exploration of these practices and their connection to sacred geometry will reveal how these ancient systems of movement and mindfulness embody universal truths.

This book invites you to journey into these interconnected realms, where the principles of psychology, philosophy, geometry, and physical movement converge. It explores how these timeless ideas remain relevant, offering practical insights for finding balance, purpose, and connection in a world that often feels fragmented. As you delve into these pages, may you uncover the patterns that shape your own existence. May you find not only knowledge but also inspiration to integrate these timeless truths into your everyday life, creating harmony within and around you.

My books are comprehensive, deeply researched, and feature original, high-quality illustrations. I have invested over 40 years of learning, practicing, and illustrating these topics myself. providing full-color printing, detailed graphics, and specialized knowledge require premium pricing. Most of my publications offer rare insights not found elsewhere, justifying their premium nature. I have specifically designed my books for serious practitioners and scholars, while also offering information for beginners to get acquainted with complex topics and concepts. Each book contains a lifetime of experience condensed into each volume. These books are for those who seek authentic, high-quality study materials rather than mass-market books.

Please contact me if you, your business, organization, or group, might be interested in hosting me to speak on a wide spectrum of topics relative to better health, fitness, and well-being.

I also have hundreds of FREE education video classes, lectures, and seminars available on my YouTube channel at:

https://www.youtube.com/c/MindandBodyExercises

Many of my publications can be found on Amazon at:

http://www.Amazon.com/author/jimmoltzan

My holistic health blog is available at:

https://mindandbodyexercises.wordpress.com/

http://www.MindAndBodyExercises.com

Mind and Body Exercises on Google: https://posts.gle/aD47Qo

Jim Moltzan

407-234-0119

Inside the Circle: The Power and Peril of Closed Groups

The Role and Risks of Closed Social Groups in Martial Arts, Yoga, Clubs, and Other Exclusive Communities

Closed social groups, such as private yoga or martial arts schools, serve a unique purpose within their respective disciplines. Depending on the intent behind their structure, their exclusivity can have advantages and drawbacks. Similar dynamics can be found in other exclusive communities, such as religious orders, secret societies, and elite academic circles.

Advantages of Closed Groups

Focused Learning Environment
- By restricting access, students or members can focus on their objectives without outside distractions or feeling self-conscious under public scrutiny. This is particularly important for traditional martial arts, esoteric yoga practices, or spiritual communities that require deep practices of observation, contemplation, and meditation as their main focus.
Preservation of Tradition
- Many closed schools and societies follow lineages that prioritize secrecy or direct transmission from teacher to student. This can help to maintain authenticity, ensuring knowledge isn’t diluted or misrepresented.
Community and Trust
- A closed structured system can encourage a strong sense of belonging, loyalty, and trust among members. This is very important for practices that involve partner training, deep introspection, or energy work, as well as in religious and esoteric orders.
Safety and Progression
- Some disciplines involve physical conditioning or internal energy cultivation such as with advanced qigong, martial techniques, or breath control methods. Restricting access ensures students have proper guidance and do not attempt techniques without foundational preparation.

Potential Disadvantages

Exclusivity Can Limit Growth
- While privacy may support depth, it may also prevent potential new students from finding and benefiting from these practices. A highly restricted group may unintentionally create an echo chamber.
Loss of Cultural Exchange
- Martial arts, yoga, and many esoteric traditions have deep historical roots but have evolved through cultural exchange. Over-restricting access could hinder the natural development of these traditions.
Risk of Elitism or Dogmatism
- If not managed well, closed groups can sometimes lead to rigid, authoritarian-type hierarchies, where senior members become resistant to new ideas or outsiders. This can lead to stagnation rather than growth.
Barrier to Understanding
- In some cases, secrecy can lead to stigma, misinformation, or misinterpretation from outsiders of the group who speculate about what happens within the group.

When Closed Groups Use Insular Dynamics

Closed groups, whether in martial arts, yoga, religious sects, secret societies, or elite academic circles, can sometimes encourage an “us vs. them” mentality, especially if they become overly insular. Various terms refer to these types of groups such as, but not limited to:

Dogmatic Communities
Ideological Isolation
Rigid Group Mentality
Sectarian Influence
Closed-System Thinking
Insulated Hierarchies
Excessive Group Loyalty
Echo Chamber Environments
Insular Traditions
Cult-like

Groupthink & Echo Chambers

Critical or objective thinking can diminish in highly insular groups as members conform to a singular worldview.
If a martial arts school, spiritual order, or elite academic group never questions its methods, or principles or refuses outside perspectives, it risks stagnation, stigma, and dogma.
Some groups discourage members from engaging with alternative viewpoints, reinforcing a “this is the only way” mindset.

Isolationism & “Us vs. Them” Mentality

If those outside of the group are viewed with hesitation, suspicion, or unworthiness, the group can become exclusionary rather than welcoming.
Some esoteric circles, religious sects, or martial arts schools forbid interactions with non-members, creating psychological dependence.
Over time, this can erode personal autonomy and discourage critical reflection.

Loaded Language & Indoctrination

Exclusive terminology or redefined words, such as “true knowledge,” “higher-level students,” “the only,” the original,” etc., can create a psychological barrier between insiders and outsiders.
Language may be used to elevate the in-group while dismissing external knowledge as inferior, dangerous or subversive.
In more extreme cases, dissenting members may be labeled as “unenlightened,” “not loyal,” “not ready,” “not qualified,” or “not clear” to justify exclusion.

Leader Worship & Hierarchical Control

Some martial arts or yoga masters, religious leaders, or academic figures present themselves as the sole gatekeeper of knowledge, discouraging students or disciples from questioning authority.
Strict obedience without space for personal growth can create an authoritarian dynamic, where members fear questioning the instructor, leader or those in authority.
This is especially risky in some of the internal arts and esoteric traditions, where progress is subjective and can be manipulated through metaphysical, mystical or vague claims.

How to Avoid or Become Aware of Insular Dynamics in Closed Groups

Encourage Critical Thinking: Healthy groups welcome questions and debate rather than discouraging independent thought.
Allow Cross-Training and Exchange: Exposure to other traditions, teachers, perspectives and resources keeps members from falling into dogma.
Maintain Ethical Boundaries: If the group expects extreme devotion, secrecy, or control over members’ lives, it’s a huge red flag.
Avoid Fear-Based Loyalty: No legitimate school or organization should use fear, guilt, or manipulation to keep members from leaving.
Foster Openness Without Dilution: A “semi-closed model,” where serious training is protected but knowledge is not hoarded, may be able to better balance tradition with accessibility.

Are Closed Groups Always Bad?

Not necessarily. Some amount of exclusivity can be beneficial for:

✅ Protecting advanced knowledge from misuse
✅ Maintaining depth and focus while training
✅ Creating a dedicated, distraction-free environment

However, if a group starts demanding absolute loyalty, rejecting all outsiders, or discouraging independent thinking, then it risks cult-like tendencies. Striking a balance between exclusivity and openness is key to ensuring that these groups remain places of learning, growth, and genuine tradition rather than echo chambers of control and manipulation.

With over 20 years of firsthand experience training, studying, and teaching in various closed groups across different settings, I have observed both their strengths and challenges. I then dedicated an additional 25 years to studying the underlying dynamics that shape these environments, recognizing both their positive and negative consequences. To deepen my understanding, I further invested four years into the study of psychology, religion, Eastern philosophy, sociology, psychophysiology, and other related fields, allowing me to analyze closed group behavior with a broader and more informed perspective.

Please contact me if you, your business, organization, or group, might be interested in hosting me to speak on a wide spectrum of topics relative to better health, fitness, and well-being.

I also have hundreds of FREE education video classes, lectures, and seminars available on my YouTube channel at:

https://www.youtube.com/c/MindandBodyExercises

Many of my publications can be found on Amazon at:

http://www.Amazon.com/author/jimmoltzan

My holistic health blog is available at:

https://mindandbodyexercises.wordpress.com/

http://www.MindAndBodyExercises.com

Mind and Body Exercises on Google: https://posts.gle/aD47Qo

Jim Moltzan

407-234-0119